Unpacking the Most Popular Thanksgiving Side Dishes of 2024

Thanksgiving is a time for indulgence, and while the turkey takes center stage, it’s the side dishes that often steal the show. According to Curiosity Aroused’ analysis of Campbell’s annual State of the Sides Report, 2024 saw some familiar favorites and a few surprises when it came to the most popular Thanksgiving side dishes across the United States.

The Reigning Champion: Stuffing Takes the Crown

Stuffing, or dressing, as it’s known in some regions, emerged as the undisputed favorite Thanksgiving side dish in 2024. With a staggering 45 out of 50 states favoring this savory delight, stuffing dethroned mashed potatoes, which had held the top spot the previous year.

The appeal of stuffing transcends generational divides, with Millennials, Baby Boomers, Generation X, and the Silent Generation all contributing to its rise to the top. Packed with aromatic herbs, bread cubes, and a melange of flavors, stuffing’s versatility and ability to capture the essence of the holiday made it a clear winner.

Mashed Potatoes: A Timeless Classic

While mashed potatoes may have slipped from the top spot, it remains a beloved staple on the Thanksgiving table. The five states that favored mashed potatoes over stuffing – California, Utah, Wyoming, Iowa, and West Virginia – demonstrated the enduring appeal of this creamy, comforting side dish.

Mashed potatoes’ ability to act as a canvas for various toppings and flavors, from gravy to cheese and bacon, ensures its place as a Thanksgiving favorite for years to come. Its familiarity and nostalgia factor only add to its charm, making it a go-to choice for families across the nation.

Sweet Potatoes: A Sweet Surprise

Sweet potatoes, often overlooked in favor of their savory counterparts, made a surprising leap to the third spot in the rankings for 2024. This humble root vegetable, commonly adorned with marshmallows or infused with warming spices like cinnamon and nutmeg, captured the hearts and palates of Thanksgiving diners nationwide.

The rise of sweet potatoes could be attributed to a growing appreciation for their nutritional value and versatility. Whether roasted, mashed, or transformed into a decadent casserole, sweet potatoes offer a delightful balance of sweetness and earthy flavors that complement the traditional Thanksgiving fare.

Green Bean Casserole: The Divisive Delight

Arguably one of the most polarizing Thanksgiving side dishes, green bean casserole secured the fourth spot in 2024’s rankings. This quirky combination of green beans, cream of mushroom soup, and crispy fried onions has become a staple on Midwestern tables, with 62 percent of households in the region serving it during the holiday.

While some may dismiss it as a culinary abomination, green bean casserole has found a devoted following among those who appreciate its nostalgic charm and unique flavor profile. Its ability to elicit strong reactions, both positive and negative, only adds to its mystique and enduring presence on Thanksgiving menus.

Macaroni and Cheese: The Kid-Friendly Favorite

Rounding out the top five is the beloved macaroni and cheese, a dish that appeals to both young and old. While it slipped from its third-place ranking in 2023, macaroni and cheese remains a crowd-pleaser, particularly among kids and members of Gen Z.

With its creamy, cheesy sauce enveloping tender pasta, macaroni and cheese offers a comforting and familiar taste that can transport diners back to their childhood. Its versatility also allows for endless variations, from adding bacon or lobster to incorporating different types of cheese, ensuring that it never grows stale on the Thanksgiving table.

Conclusion

As the Thanksgiving feast continues to evolve, one thing remains constant: the pivotal role side dishes play in creating a memorable and satisfying dining experience. From the classic appeal of stuffing and mashed potatoes to the unexpected rise of sweet potatoes and the divisive allure of green bean casserole, the 2024 rankings showcase the diverse palates and traditions that shape the American Thanksgiving celebration.

Whether you’re a purist or an adventurer when it comes to your side dish selections, the beauty of Thanksgiving lies in the ability to embrace both cherished traditions and new culinary adventures. So, as you gather around the table this year, take a moment to savor the flavors and stories that each side dish brings to the feast, and revel in the joy of sharing a meal with loved ones.